Can You Turn a Rainbow Back into White Light?

You know, [music] when I look at a rainbow, I always think, I wonder if it's possible to recombine that back into white light. >> Sorry, why am I here? >> They just like you being in videos. Well, I like you in the last one. I don't know. Just obviously I'm not talking about plucking a rainbow out of the sky. But as you probably know, Newton was able to make rainbows with prisms. Basically, Newton drilled a hole in his blinds, put a big prism in the middle of the room, and when a beam of sunlight hit the prism, it turned into a rainbow. But I want to see if I can do the reverse, and turn a rainbow into a beam of white light. You might think that I could just take a second prism, flip it the other way, and put that in front of the rainbow, and that would turn the rainbow back into a beam of white light. But that doesn't work. That's the first challenge. The second challenge is, well, this is just VFX. That's why I didn't actually put the prism there, cuz I mean, how would you get that right in VFX? Don't have the budget for that. The point is, you wouldn't actually get a beam of white light in the air. And you wouldn't see a rainbow in the air. You'd only see the rainbow projected onto the screen. But for this video, I wanted you to be able to see the whole journey of the light from beginning to end. So that's why I need a ray table. You might have played with one, a science center. It's basically a vertical shaft of light. And so you can put things in front of it, you know, like optical elements, lenses, and mirrors and things like that. But importantly, this vertical shaft of light is fanning out a little bit vertically. So there's always some part of the beam hitting the table, and so [music] you can see the path of the light and how it changes as it interacts with different optical elements. It looks a bit rubbish at the moment, but after a lot of fapping about, I got it looking really nice in the camera. And because I couldn't figure out how to do it in VFX, here's what actually happens when [music] you put a flipped prism immediately after the first prism. It doesn't work. I'm pretty sure there's a solution, though. But actually, why doesn't this work? To find out, let's return to our old friend, Sir Isaac Newton. That's not the conceit, though. >> What do you mean? >> No, I'm not Isaac Newton. >> No, like in the last bit, I was saying Isaac Newton did this, Isaac Newton did that. You mean like the conceit is I'm Steve Mold dressed as Isaac Newton. That's a bit weird though. >> Yeah, I agree. The reason you need more than just a second prism is because of the way light bends when it goes from air to glass. This is refraction. This is what we need to understand. There's more than one way to explain why light bends when it goes from air to glass. But it always comes down to the fact that light slows down when it enters the glass. But why does that lead to the light bending? Well, my favorite way of looking at it is in terms of wavefronts. So, we've got these wavefronts approaching the glass at an angle. Now consider just one point on one of those wavefronts and see that it slows down when it enters the glass. But now see what that looks like when we reintroduce all of the other points from all of the other wavefronts. And look that's quite clear. If we assume that light always travels perpendicular to the wavefront then well clearly the light has bent. So light slows down when it goes from air to glass and that changes its direction. But crucially, the amount by which the light slows down depends on the wavelength of the light. So blue light with a short wavelength is bent more and red light with a longer wavelength is bent less. And so the white light fans out into a spectrum and then it fans out even more when it goes from glass back to air. You might be wondering why different wavelengths bend different amounts. >> I'm actually just really cold, >> but actually it's beyond the scope of this video. And in fact, Grant did a great explanation over on three blue, one brown. Link to that video in the description. So, when the light leaves the prism, it's in a kind of fan shape. That means when it hits the second prism, each wavelength of light has [music] its own unique spot along that boundary between air and glass. The flipped prism will bend all those different wavelengths [music] of light by just the right amount so that they end up parallel with each other when they leave the prism. But because they entered the prism in different locations, all these different colors won't be on top of each other. [music] In other words, we end up with a parallel rainbow beam instead of a beam of white light. You know, with some videos, a lot of the process is just solving procurement problems, like finding a lens that's tall enough, finding an Isaac Newton costume, etc., etc. And inevitably, I end up with loads of browser tabs open. If you find yourself in that situation, can I recommend tab islands from the sponsor of this video, Opera? See, if I just drag one tab over another, it creates a tab island and I can put all the shopping tabs in there. And so now I've got all these different tab islands. Like this one is for explanation related things. This one's about production and post-production. And look, I can collapse and expand them as needed and even choose a color and a name for them, which is pretty cool. But actually, if there's one reason to download Opera, it's to try tab traces. Like when you have lots of tabs open, you can spend a lot of time just searching for that one specific tab that you need. And what tab traces do is give you a kind of visual hot or cold. The way it works is the darker the underscore, the more recently you've visited that tab. So, it just helps me to zero in on the one I'm looking for. You have to try it really. It's like magic. A couple more features I'll show you. There's the detachable music player, which you can basically put anywhere. It could be inside the browser, outside the browser, and crucially, if you start watching a YouTube video, the music pauses automatically. It works with Spotify, Apple Music, a whole bunch of others. And if you're anything like me, you like to tweak things so that they're just so. And fortunately with Opera, the UI is endlessly customizable. My favorite theme at the moment is this one because, well, I mean, just look at it. It's super easy to give it a try. So, click the link in the description to download Opera today. Okay, but what about this parallel rainbow beam problem? How do we solve that? Well, what we really need is to take the mirror image of this side. We need the rainbow to be converging to a [music] point when it enters the second prism. So how do we do that? Well, I think the answer is in this book, [music] Newton's Optics, published in 1704. I think this is a first edition, actually. You see, Newton had a problem. He needed to prove everyone wrong because the prevailing wisdom at the time was that white light was pure light coming from the sun. Well, of course it was pure. It was coming from the heavens. And if light changed color, like if sunlight passed through a stained [music] glass window, it's because the stained glass window was literally staining the light. and prisms were simply devices that stained the pure white light, the whole rainbow of colors. To prove them wrong, Newton really wanted to be able to take the spectrum of all colors and recombine them into a beam of white light. And look on page 156, there it is, a convex lens. To show you this in action, I just need to fix my rubbish setup a little bit. Firstly, these optical elements have a chamfer at the bottom. So, every time we introduce a new element to this [music] ray table, the shadow cast by this chamfer gets longer until it's kind of unusable. So, I've laser cut some holes in this white board for the optical elements to sit in, [music] and that just kind of removes the chamfer, so there's no more dead spots. Also, the prisms that come with this ray table are rubbish. They're too short for a start. Also, they're not the optimum way to bend light. I've gone for these ones. They're a bit taller and they're made of flint glass. Flint glass bends light a lot, but more importantly, the amount it bends blue and red differs by a larger amount, so you get a wider fan. And then the lens that came with the ray table kit, that's too short. So, I ended up getting this one. This is really nice. The focal length is 75 mm, meaning parallel rays would be focused at 75 mm. But I want the object in the image to be the same distance from the lens, which means I need to double that. So I need a separation of 150 mm. And so look on the other side, the rainbow is now focused back to a point. And look what happens if I put a little screen there and slowly move it backwards. Eventually, all those colors are combined to form white light. But we're not satisfied with that because look, if I keep moving the screen back, well, it turns back into a rainbow again. But I want a straight beam of white light. And for that, I think we need another upgrade because, well, the light source just isn't strong enough. I tried a few things. I tried to make a massive light box. The best solution in the end was to fit a bulb in here that's actually overrated for this enclosure. We're pumping out 50 watts instead of 20. So, we just have to not run it for too long. One bit of nerdy detail I think you'll like about filming this thing is when you're looking at it in person, you're taking [snorts] in the whole scene. Your eyes looking over here, your eyes looking over here. Your eyes are constantly adjusting for how much light is coming in. But the reality is that this end is much brighter than this end, which looks kind of rubbish in the camera. So I put this special filter over my camera lens. It's typically used when you want the sky in a scene not to be overexposed. But by turning it sideways, I was able to roughly even out the amount of light coming into the camera. Okay, so the convex lens focuses the rainbow to a point. That's where we put the second prism, which unbends each wavelength of light by the exact amount that the first prism bent the light in the first place. And so coming out of that second prism, we have all the different colors all moving in the same direction, and they're all on top of each other. And so there you go. We have our beam of white light back again. I mean, look, I can put the screen all the way over here and it's still working. How cool is that? And I mean, I've got to say, looks flipping beautiful, doesn't it? The reason I wanted to get this experiment working is because it was the defining experiment that proved Newton Wright. The experimentum crusing the spectrum into white light, he overturned the prevailing wisdom that white light from the sun was pure. And of course, as we now know, white light is made up of all the colors of the rainbow.

Try Tab Traces and everything else Opera has to offer: https://opr.as/Opera-browser-stevemould Newton proved that white light was made of all the colours of rainbow by recombining the spectrum. He used a second prism and a convex lens. 3b1b why different wavelengths of light bend different amounts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KTzGBJPuJwM You can buy my books here: https://stevemould.com/books You can support me on Patreon and get access to the exclusive Discord: https://www.patreon.com/stevemould Twitter: http://twitter.com/moulds Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stevemouldscience/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/stevemouldscience/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/stevemould Buy nerdy maths things: http://mathsgear.co.uk