bouncer
← Back

Podcast Maddow: Trump in retreat as disastrous anti-immigrant campaign becomes political catastrophe

The Rachel Maddow Show · 45:09 · 77d ago

Queued Transcribing Analyzing Complete
70% High Human

"Be aware of the intense moral outrage framing that makes opposition to the Trump administration feel like moral imperative, though it's openly presented as editorial commentary."

MildModerateSevere

Transparency

Transparent

Primary Technique

Us vs. Them

Dividing the world into two camps — people like us (good, trustworthy) and people not like us (dangerous, wrong). It exploits a deep human tendency to favor our own group. Once you accept the division, information from "them" gets automatically discounted.

Tajfel's Social Identity Theory (1979); Minimal Group Paradigm

The episode reports on the Trump administration retreating from a large-scale immigration enforcement operation in Minneapolis amid widespread protests following the killing of Alex Preddy by Border Patrol agents, highlighting nationwide solidarity and democratic resistance. No covert mechanisms operate beneath it; the moral framing and emotional appeals are overt hallmarks of Rachel Maddow's transparent opinion journalism on a self-selected audience.

Listen

Provenance Signals

The content exhibits the distinct personal voice, complex sentence structures, and journalistic rigor associated with Rachel Maddow's long-form reporting. The presence of spontaneous linguistic nuances and the specific handling of breaking news updates are hallmarks of human-led editorial production.

Natural Speech Patterns Use of self-correction ('I don't know. We don't know'), conversational fillers, and rhetorical flourishes ('in which direction they shall roll') typical of live broadcast journalism.
Source Attribution and Nuance The speaker carefully distinguishes between their own network's reporting and unconfirmed reporting from The Atlantic, providing context on the reporter's reputation.
Ad-Read Integration The transcript includes a standard podcast ad-break transition (Blue Air) followed by a natural re-entry into the news segment.
Episode Description
Donald Trump's anti-immigrant mission was already damaging his standing with the portion of Americans who didn't already dislike him, but the escalating violence and brutality and shocking on-camera killings have seen his opposition balloon from Americans protesting to a large swath of his own party, business leaders, clergy and Congress. Rachel Maddow outlines how the forces of democracy are imposing themselves on Trump.Rachel Maddow points out the consistent, unrelenting, stalwart, peaceful opposition of the people of Minnesota to Donald Trump's brutal anti-immigrant tactics, flexing every democratic muscle, is steadily defeating Trump. The people of Minneapolis are showing that the way to save democracy is by democratic means, including peaceful protest.Rachel Maddow reports on the expanding list of communities that are refusing the admit the Department of Homeland Security to install an immigration prison or processing facility in their area. Even across differences of politics and demographics, no one wants to be host to an immigration prison. Want more of Rachel? Check out the "Rachel Maddow Presents" feed to listen to all of her chart-topping original podcasts.To listen to all of your favorite MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Worth Noting

Offers detailed, sourced updates on specific personnel changes (e.g., Greg Bovino's removal) and maps of nationwide protests with locations and turnout estimates.

Be Aware

Us vs. Them framing that positions protesters as unambiguous democratic heroes while depicting the administration as morally failed aggressors.

Influence Dimensions

How are these scored?
Descriptions of federal agents' 'violent occupation' and killing of Alex Preddy → elicits grief and anger → reinforces narrative of Trump retreat without hidden agenda beyond overt advocacy

Moral outrage

Provoking a sense that something is deeply unfair or wrong, activating a feeling that demands action — sharing, protesting, punishing — before you've fully evaluated the situation. It's one of the most viral emotions online because it combines anger with righteousness.

Haidt's Moral Foundations Theory (2004); Brady et al. (2017, PNAS)

Pathos

Appealing to your emotions — fear, joy, anger, sadness — to make an argument feel compelling. Rather than persuading through evidence, it works by putting you in an emotional state where you're more receptive. The emotion becomes the proof.

Aristotle's Rhetoric; Kahneman's System 1 processing

Protests and democratic actions as sole cause of admin retreat → excludes admin perspective on operation's goals or necessity → benefits anti-Trump narrative expected from this host

Single-cause framing

Attributing a complex outcome to a single cause, ignoring the web of contributing factors. A clean explanation is more satisfying and easier to act on than a complicated one. Especially effective when the proposed cause is something you already dislike.

Fallacy of the single cause; Kahneman's WYSIATI principle

Moral framing

Presenting a complex issue with genuine tradeoffs as a simple choice between right and wrong. Once something is framed as a moral issue, compromise feels like complicity and disagreement feels immoral rather than reasonable.

Haidt's Moral Foundations Theory; Lakoff's framing research (2004)

Federal investigations of local leaders are politically motivated abuses → assumes DOJ independence is eroded, treated as obvious in progressive context

Loaded language

Using emotionally charged words where neutral ones would be more accurate. Calling the same policy 'reform' vs. 'gutting,' or the same people 'freedom fighters' vs. 'terrorists,' triggers different reactions to identical facts. The word choice does the persuading.

Hayakawa's Language in Thought and Action (1949); Lakoff's framing (2004)

Trump agents as 'unhinged' killers in 'paramilitary attack'; protesters/clergy as heroic → flattens groups to serve victory narrative

Character flattening

Reducing a complex person to one defining trait — hero, villain, genius, fool — stripping away nuance that would complicate the narrative. Once someone is labeled, everything they do gets interpreted through that lens.

Fundamental attribution error (Ross, 1977); Propp's narrative archetypes (1928)

In-group/Out-group framing

Leveraging your tendency to automatically trust information from "our people" and distrust outsiders. Once groups are established, people apply different standards of evidence depending on who is speaking.

Social Identity Theory (Tajfel & Turner, 1979); Cialdini's Unity principle (2016)

About this analysis

Knowing about these techniques makes them visible, not powerless. The ones that work best on you are the ones that match beliefs you already hold.

This analysis is a tool for your own thinking — what you do with it is up to you.

Analyzed: 16d ago
Transcript

Kids need to feel safe at school so that they can flourish. I always make sure that my students are well fed. I make sure that everyone gets breakfast. The most important thing is that to listen to them. The social emotional learning is something that I've really focused on. There's a check-in. They know that I care about them, so I'm checking in with them. That's one of our classroom rules, how we're all friends and we're all respectful. It's a matter of welcoming everybody. That's one way that I'm making sure that my students are in a good headspace. Performance comes down to controlling what you can. For Jessica Pagula, it starts with the air around her. A Blue Air user for over five years, she trusts Blue Signature air purifiers, engineered to perform and designed to impress. Shop BlueAir.com and use code Signature30. Really happy to have you here tonight as President Donald Trump and the Trump administration bend and then break under pressure that it turns out they cannot handle. They underestimated the people of Minnesota and the strength of feeling in this country right now in support of the people of Minneapolis. Tonight, the Trump administration is pulling Border Patrol official Greg Bovino and some number of Border Patrol agents out of Minneapolis. We do not know if this is the end of what they've been calling Operation Metro Surge, this sustained, very large-scale paramilitary attack. on the cities of Minneapolis and St. Paul. We don't know if it is the end of that operation full stop, but we know it's the end of something. Our latest reporting here at MSNOW, per our reporters Carol Lennig and Mark Santia, is this, quote, according to two officials briefed on the matter, Gregory Bovino is expected to be removed from commanding the operation in Minnesota, possibly as early as tomorrow, meaning Tuesday. There will also be a reduction of Homeland security officers and agents in the state. Again, that's new reporting from MSNOW. We're also aware of new reporting in the Atlantic tonight. And this is reporting that we have not confirmed ourselves, but I'll tell you that reporter Nick Miroff, who has an excellent reputation, at the Atlantic tonight, he reports this under the headline, quote, Greg Bovino loses his job. Quote, Greg Bovino has been removed from his role as Border Patrol commander at large and will return to his former job in El Centro, California, where he is expected to retire soon, according to a Homeland Security official and two people with knowledge of the change. Bovino's sudden demotion is the clearest sign yet that the Trump administration is reconsidering its most aggressive tactics after the killing Saturday of 37-year-old Alex Preddy by Border Patrol agents under Bovino's command. Nick Miroff reports, quote, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and her close advisor, Corey Lewandowski, who were Bovino's biggest backers at Homeland Security, are now also at risk of losing their jobs. Miroff citing two sources to advance that story about Kristi Noem and Lewandowski potentially losing their jobs as well. Again, reporting from reporter Nick Miroff, he's formerly of The Washington Post, but he's now at The Atlantic. Tonight, the Homeland Security Department spokesperson said that Bovino, quote, has not been relieved of his duties. Chief Gregory Bovino has not been relieved of his duties. Which sounds like pushback, but if you think about it, it doesn't exactly answer the question. I mean, that assertion that he has not been relieved of his duties might, in fact, be quite consistent with the reporting in The Atlantic that Mr. Bovino has been sent home to California where he is expected to retire soon. That could also be true while tonight he has not been relieved of his duties. I don't know. We don't know what heads will roll or exactly in which direction they shall roll. We shall see. But clearly, President Trump and the Trump administration are in retreat on what had been a violent occupation, I think it's fair to say, of a major American city, that they essentially hoped to be the front page news headline that everybody remembered about the Trump administration at this time, at the start of Trump's second year in his second term in office. They went big with this on their own terms. Nobody asked for this. Nobody put them up to it. They decided to launch this in order to show off what they could do. And now they are in full retreat with it being viewed both as a practical debacle and a moral debacle. And they are paying a considerable political price for it. If you were one of millions of Americans who protested ICE out of Minneapolis, you should know tonight you are winning this thing. And it's worth understanding the power of what you have done. President Trump today and tonight held conciliatory phone calls with the Democratic governor of Minnesota, Tim Walls, and the Democratic mayor of Minneapolis, Jacob Fry. Both of those elected officials were demonized by Trump and by the Trump administration up until like 30 seconds ago. Once Trump started criticizing both of those elected officials, his U.S. Department of Justice naturally put both of them under federal investigation of some kind. since that's how federal law enforcement works now. The president gets mad at you or wants to hurt you for some reason, and bingo, magically you're instantly the subject of a federal criminal or civil investigation by the FBI and the U.S. Department of Justice. Even with those threats, though, even with those investigations launched against them, those threats against Minnesota elected leaders seem to have had the opposite of the intended effect on them. It seems to have caused them to dig in and fight harder. It definitely increased their political support both in their state and around the country. Similarly, the federal government's threats to the people of Minneapolis. Federal agents increasingly unhinged and explosive violence toward the people of Minneapolis. They're killing people protesting and observing and filming federal agents in Minneapolis. That also seems to have had the opposite of their intended effect. It caused more people to commit more to being in the streets more of the time, to come out in larger numbers, to come out with more resolve and honestly with more emotion. It definitely sent support for them soaring all around the country. On Friday, you'll recall there were huge marches and demonstrations in Minneapolis, a day in which the whole city of Minneapolis basically shut down. Kids home from school, people didn't go to work. People agreed that they would spend nothing that day, transact no business that day. They instead spent the day in prayer and protest and finding new ways to stand up for each other, including these dozens of members of the clergy who were arrested Friday morning at the Minneapolis-St. Paul Airport. They were there urging Delta Airlines and Signature Aviation and other companies with business at the airport to stop cooperating with ICE. peaceful civil disobedience by members of the clergy, dozens of whom were arrested at the start of the day, Friday morning in that bitter, bitter sub-zero cold. It was the next day, Saturday, when Trump's federal agents killed Alex Preddy in the street. And the streets filled instantly in response, in protest and anger and grief. And by that night, there were protests and vigils all over the city and on Sunday as well, just everywhere in Minneapolis. At the site where they killed him, at Whittier Park in that same neighborhood where they killed him, in downtown at Minneapolis City Hall, and communities all over the city, retirement homes, right, where octogenarians came out into the bitter minus 20 degree weather to hold candles in vigil for Alex Preddy and for their city. still today. This was a walkout today at the University of Minnesota Twin Cities campus. But it wasn't only Minneapolis standing up for themselves. I mean, this was Davenport, Iowa. This is six hours away from Minneapolis. We stand with Minnesota. This was 600 miles away in Grand Rapids, Michigan. In the cold and the snow, Grand Rapids stands with Minnesota. This was 1,600 miles away. In Orlando, Florida, ICE murders again. This was Green Bay, Wisconsin, where Alex Preddy went to high school. The high temperature was a grand total of seven degrees. See all the people there on the bridge? People came out in the cold and the ice and marched in his name and to stand up for Minneapolis. In Phoenix, Arizona, protests convened at the ICE field office in Phoenix. Big protests there, Saturday night. Salt Lake City, Utah, Protests convened at the federal building there. Look at that. Again, Saturday. This is instant. No advance notice. People just convened there on an emergency basis, essentially, after hearing the news. They were everywhere on zero notice. In anger at ICE and at the Trump administration and in memory of Alex Preddy and in support of the people of Minneapolis. Here was Milwaukee, Wisconsin this weekend. Here was New York City, really big protest in New York City convened on zero notice Saturday afternoon after Alex Preddy was killed Saturday morning. Here was Seattle. Here was Tampa, Florida. Tampa on the right there, Seattle on the left. Here was Colorado Springs, Colorado in the bitter, bitter cold and the snow. Here was Boise City Hall in Idaho. And Idaho, deep red Idaho, actually had more protests than just Boise. Also in Twin Falls, Idaho, and Idaho Falls and Coeur d'Alene. There was a huge, huge protest in Chicago. And of course, Chicago has been through it themselves. But a huge number of Chicagoans turned out in the cold and the snow to stand up for Minneapolis as well. In Omaha, Nebraska, they came out. In San Francisco, California. In Los Angeles, California. In Sacramento, California. In Charleston, South Carolina. In Lantana, Florida. Traverse City, Michigan. It was absolutely frigid. They had 2,000 people out. We stand with Minneapolis. And, you know, at every protest I've ever been to, every protest I've ever covered, as long as it's a protest that's happening in the English language, which everyone I've ever been to or seen, somebody at some point starts up the chant, this is what democracy looks like, right? We've all heard that so much. It has become like protest wallpaper. It almost feels like generic sentiment, right? This is what democracy looks like. But it is literally true. It is what democracy looks like. Peaceful protest is a core part of democratic action, small d democratic action. And the unromantic, strong, simple truth of the matter is that in our country right now, every small d democratic muscle that we have is flexing. And it turns out that that's way stronger than Donald Trump and way stronger than the worst designs of the Trump administration. United, persistent, earnest, creative, peaceful protests that have not relented for a minute in Minneapolis. Everybody from clergy to professional sports teams to unions to school parent groups to school kids themselves to indivisible groups to Native American activists to people who had never previously protested a single thing in their lives I mean every day nevertheless protesting demonstrating telling Trump agents to get out never giving them a moment peace spontaneous instinctual and then ultimately organized mutual aid community support alerting people to the presence of federal agents walking people kids to and from school dropping off groceries to families too afraid for good reason to get out of their house doing know your rights trainings everywhere responding in person when people are being attacked or taken Not being afraid when Trump's masked agents turn those very things into life-threatening confrontations. Or being afraid, but still doing it anyway. And from the ground up, that huge effort by regular people in Minneapolis and people supporting them all around the country, it set everything in motion. And now we are seeing what's called political pushback that is so widespread and that is so relentless and that is so strong. There is no resisting it, even if you say don't believe in democracy. Local elected officials encouraging the peaceful protests, asking people to keep recording everything they can about the behavior of these lawless paramilitaries. You then see local elected officials out among the people. I mean, this was Governor Tim Walz and his wife had a vigil for Renee Good. This past Friday, Senator Amy Klobuchar and her husband at the huge peaceful protests in Minneapolis. We're going to speak with Senator Klobuchar in just a moment. I mean, you have you have Democratic force massed on one side of this issue. And on the other side, they have guns and tear gas and physical brutality and menace. and their propaganda about how terrible immigrants are and how terrible, you know, how everybody's against them as a communist or whatever. I mean, that's what they've got. They've got physical force, weapons, menace, and propaganda. That's what they've got on their side. But there is massed, committed, small-D democratic force of great resolve against that on the other. And guess which side wins? And so after they killed Alex Preddy on Saturday, we very quickly saw it all fall apart for them. Not because somebody defeated them in physical battle, right? They're the ones who are geared up like the way they're going to win, the way they're going to overthrow this democracy is in some kind of war, right? They can just have just the right military gear and just the right threatening, physical, intimidating force. That'll be how they win. Right. That's how they think they'll win. With guns. The people of this country on the other side, the opponents of that overthrow, the population of this country that is committed to, you know, no kings and they're never being a dictator here. They know that the way they're going to win is not with guns, is not in a war. The people on the other side of this fight, they know the way they're going to save American democracy is by using American democratic means to do so. And that means protest and speech and political power. After months of protest, what happened when they killed Alex Preddy? There was a small D democratic flex against which the Trump administration just crumbled. I mean, Republicans in the Minnesota state legislature, quote, it's clear that Operation Metro Surge is causing more harm than good. It needs to end. We need to, quote, de-escalate. We need to, quote, pause targeted operations. Again, that's Minnesota Republicans in the legislature. A leading Republican candidate for governor in Minnesota drops out of the race for governor today. A surprise announcement, quote, Republican Chris Madel made a stunning exit from the Minnesota governor's race today, saying he cannot support the National Republican Party's stated retribution on the citizens of our state, nor can I count myself a member of a party that would do so. The lead in the Star Tribune, quote, in a surprise video announcement, he said, United States citizens, particularly those of color, live in fear. U.S. citizens are carrying papers to prove their citizenship. That's wrong. Madel called ICE's Operation Metro Surge in Minnesota, quote, an unmitigated disaster, saying at the end of the day, quote, I have to look my daughters in the eye and tell them I believe I did what was right. And I'm doing that today. As he quit his race for governor as a Republican, saying he could not stand right now to run in Minnesota as a Republican. It's also Republicans in Congress. Quote, the events in Minneapolis are incredibly disturbing. The credibility of ICE and DHS are at stake. There must be a full joint federal and state investigation. We can trust the American people with the truth. Quote, a thorough investigation is necessary to get to the bottom of these incidents and to maintain Americans' confidence in our justice system. Republican governors, Republican governors, too, quote, enough. It's not acceptable for American citizens to be killed by federal agents for exercising their God-given and constitutional rights to protest their government. At best, these federal immigration operations are a complete failure of coordination of acceptable public safety and law enforcement practices, training and leadership. At worst, it's a deliberate federal intimidation and incitement of American citizens that's resulting in the murder of Americans. Another Republican governor, quote, what we're seeing on TV, it's causing deep concerns over federal tactics and accountability. Americans don't like what they're seeing right now. Another Republican governor, the Trump administration needs, quote, to recalibrate on what needs to be done. Recalibrate. the Democrats in Congress moving to on the Senate side, even Democratic senators who have sided with Republicans in the past who have voted to fund the Trump administration when other Democrats didn't want to do that. Even those Democratic senators, basically all the, you know, the so-called moderates, the conservative Democrats, they came out and said they will not vote to fund the Department of Homeland Security and ICE. And that is a vote that has to happen this week. Democrats saying they are not going to do it even if they have done it before. In the House, the number of members of Congress who are signing up to an effort there to impeach Kristi Noem, the Homeland Security Secretary, that races up to well over, look at that, 140 co-sponsors. I was going to say over 100 now. It's now at 140 co-sponsors of the resolution to impeach Kristi Noem as Homeland Security Secretary. And last week, there were a handful of House Democrats who did vote to fund the Department of Homeland Security. Those handful of House Democrats who voted to fund the Department of Homeland Security last week have this week started apologizing for it. Democrat Tom Swasey in New York, quote, I failed to view the Homeland Security funding vote as a referendum on the illegal and immoral conduct of ICE in Minneapolis. I hear the anger from many of my constituents, and I take responsibility for that. I have long been critical of ICE's unlawful behavior, and I must do a better job demonstrating that. Some Democrats changing their previous position to say now they will not vote to fund ICE, and some Democrats who already voted to fund ICE saying, oh, wow, that was wrong. I'm so sorry. I didn't get it. I'll do better. This is called political change. And even in the sinkhole of sniveling cowardice that has been America's business so-called leaders, even there, they're starting to ever so tentatively squeak that maybe, possibly, if nobody minds, they might want to express that they're mildly uncomfortable with what Trump and the Trump administration are doing. chief executives of Target, Best Buy, General Mills, Cargill, Land O'Lakes, Hormel, U.S. Bank Corp., the Mayo Clinic, 3M, and dozens of other large Minnesota employers issued a public letter Sunday calling for, quote, an immediate de-escalation, an immediate de-escalation in their state. And yes, that is too little. And yes, that is too late. But it is way more than they were willing to do before. So take it, bank it, and build on it. We even saw some of the old graybeards of U.S. politics rouse from their retirement pastimes and diversions to say something. President Barack Obama and President Bill Clinton each issuing pretty stirring statements condemning Trump's attack on Minneapolis and praising the strong, peaceful protests of the people there in response. And, you know, we are conditioned to be bored and underwhelmed by anything done in Congress. And honestly, you know, by Congress, by candidates, by brand name politicians, by even state elected leaders, we are conditioned to expect that the actions of anyone in politics who is not currently the president are just, you know, not very powerful actions. They're just not very important. but we are conditioned to believe that in a way that is not actually keeping faith with who we're supposed to be as a country. Because what we inherited from the founding fathers of this country is a democracy that was explicitly and purposefully designed to be decentralized and divided and responsive to the people. And when the people push in a concerted way, what we are seeing is that the country is working the way it's supposed to. The levers of power are moving. There is a political response, a small d democratic response. And yes, that means the president's poll numbers sink further into the bedrock, including on immigration, which he really at one point wanted to be his signature issue. And he is now running from. But the other forces of political gravity start to work on him as well. He may not want to be subject to democratic force, but he is. And in Congress and in state government and in party politics and in business, which to them all means money as well as power, you are seeing political shift happening. And that is because of the people. It starts with the people. It starts with the protests that we have seen. Principled, peaceful, relentless protest. It works. That is the source of this shift. peaceful, powerful, relentless, principled protest works. It uses democratic means to save democracy. That is what has made all of this political shifting happen. That is what has forced the Trump administration to change course. That is what has forced Trump to back down. principle, peaceful, relentless protest is the democratic means of saving a democracy. And that is the only way to win for the long term. So as they pull Gregory Bovino and federal agents out of Minneapolis tonight, be very clear on why this happened. If you were part of those protests, if you were part of the peaceful democratic advocacy to get ICE out of Minneapolis. Tonight, you are winning. And there's a lot going on. There's a lot to cover tonight. We got an update tonight on the places all over the country where Trump is trying to put new immigrant prison camps They want to build a whole new network of massive prison camps that are effectively black sites where there little to no legal access where they want to indefinitely imprison men women and children And we are now seeing in red states and blue states, in urban areas and suburban areas and small towns and rural areas, everywhere they are trying to cite one of these prison camps. You are seeing Americans of all stripes, even local Republican officials, standing up and saying no to that, saying, no, we are not going to let you build one of your camps here where we live. So we're going to have an update on those efforts tonight. Also, some striking imagery out of Texas. This weekend, there was an uprising in one of these camps in Texas. Men, women and children held in one of these Trump prison camps, rebelling this weekend in Texas, demonstrating they were calling explicitly for the children in that camp to be set free. We're going to talk tonight with a lawyer who happened to be there when that peaceful uprising happened. The authorities rushed him out as soon as it started. They forced him to leave, but not before he was able to capture some of it on video. We're going to speak live with him in just a moment. We've got Senator Amy Klobuchar joining us live from Minnesota. We've got a lot to get to tonight. Democracy at work. Stay with us. What do you know about the Family Detention Center in Dilley, Texas? It's where our government imprisons immigrant parents, children, and even newborns, a place with putrid drinking water, food with bugs and worms, and even a confirmed measles outbreak. These conditions are unsafe and inhumane. The Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, or RAICES, is the only legal aid provider inside Dili, day in and day out. We're there right now, defending immigrants' rights to due process and filing emergency petitions to free families illegally detained. You can fuel our fight to protect the rights of our children, our neighbors, and all of us. Donate at freeallfamilies.org. That's freeallfamilies.org SQ.org slash rebuild. Performance comes down to controlling what you can. For Jessica Pagula, it starts with the air around her. A Blue Air user for over five years, she trusts Blue Signature air purifiers. Engineered to perform and designed to impress. Shop BlueAir.com and use code Signature30. The high, the hottest part of the day, the high was negative nine degrees. The low was negative 20. If you factor in the windchill, it was in the negative 40s. It was quite literally one of the coldest days in Minneapolis in years. But thousands of Minnesotans came out to protest anyway. Organizers estimate that somewhere between 50,000 and 75,000 people turned out in Minneapolis on Friday to insist that ICE and Trump's federal agents get out of their city. Among them in that brittle, bitter cold was Minnesota Democratic U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar marching with her constituents, demanding an end to the chaotic, violent surge of federal agents in Minneapolis and around that state. Again, that was Friday. It was less than 24 hours later when Trump's federal agents shot and killed 37-year-old ICU nurse Alex Preddy on those same streets. Alex Preddy is the third person federal agents have shot in Minneapolis in three weeks. He's the second person they have killed. Amy Klobuchar has represented Minnesota in the U.S. Senate since 2007. And she's now wearing two very important hats in the politics of that state. In addition to representing Minnesotans in the U.S. Capitol currently, she's also at least considering a campaign to try to become Minnesota's governor. Last week, she filed the preliminary paperwork required to run for governor. She hasn't announced that she is running, but by filing that paperwork, she is at least keeping the option open. And so with Trump's federal agents forcing her state into a state of chaos, Senator Klobuchar now finds herself with a large and interesting and complex role to play as both a leader in the Senate and a potential future governor. We have warned this administration, I have personally warned them, that there would be more deaths, that more of this would happen. And clearly they're not listening. So we ask people around the country to talk to their Republican representatives to make clear that this is not the America that is ours. This has got to stop. Joining us now live is Senator Amy Klobuchar, Democrat of Minnesota. Senator, it's nice to see you. Thank you for being with us tonight. I know it's a really difficult time. First, let me ask you. I really appreciated your. Go ahead. Well, I just appreciated how you captured this idea that Minnesota is, yes, been the center of America's heartbreak. But we have also been the center of America's courage and America's hope and how ordinary people have just done the most extraordinary things that have gotten to this point. They have stood up. They have marched. They have brought food to their neighbors and they have not blinked. And I think it is something that we have learned now about how you take on this kind of just abuse of power where they have crossed the line of legality, morality and decency. And it is a long way from a victory. But the fact that they are pulling out the federal agents as we speak and Bambino, who is just in this same TV studio I'm in today, 24 hours ago, was in the same room with me, is now gone. Let me ask your I guess your reaction, your understanding of what kind of change the federal government is making. And I know that you said publicly at the press conference this weekend there's been reporting that you have had some communications with the Trump administration. Did you have any word that this was going to happen? Did you have any sense in advance that this was going to be what they did? Yes, this morning I got a call early from the White House and some texts from the president's chief of staff later in the day about what was going to happen here. And this is a long haul of standing up publicly, calling them out, standing with our police chiefs who have been very strong, Minneapolis, suburban areas, our mayor, our governor, our attorney general, Keith Ellison. And all of us saying enough is enough for congressional delegation on the Democratic side and then pleading with our Republican colleagues. And finally, this weekend, after the horrendous murder followed, of course, after the murder, the killing of Renee Good. And now you have the killing of Alex Preddy talking to his parents last night when they told me how offended they were crying the entire time about the lies about him when he had devoted his life to taking care of our veterans. And they go out, administration officials calling him a domestic terrorist, calling Renee Good a domestic terrorist. So all of this just has culminated in this moment where people across our state, regardless of political ideology, mounting time and time again, have said enough. We have had enough. Get ICE out of our state and stop these abusive tactics, taking Hmong elders out of their homes, dragging them out in their underwear and then figuring out they had the wrong guy because he was already in jail. taking two-year-olds, sending them to Texas, my office up through the night trying to get that kid back on a plane, which we were able to do so she could be united with her mother, five-year-olds with Spiderman backpacks. It just goes on and on and on. And it is the biggest abuse I have ever seen of people's civil rights. And the fact that there is now some de-escalation and that they are willing now to talk to our leaders and our police officers and let them do their real jobs and get ICE out of our state is truly a moment, but we have to see it bear out to its finality. And they can't keep doing this all around our country as well. To that point, there is a decision that needs to be made at the U.S. Senate this week in terms of funding DHS. It's a it's a bill. They call it a minibus. It funds like five major components of the government. a little more than half of the total operations of the government, including DHS. What's going to happen there? What's your what's your expectation this week for that bill? And what would be the impact if if that that funding for DHS didn't pass? Well, as you pointed out, there are more and more Democrats. I've signaled my opposition, as did Senator Smith weeks ago to this and voted against that. A big, beautiful betrayal of the bill that was seventy five billion dollars added to the ICE budget. So they are now bigger than the FBI. And now we have had a number of Democrats, Senator Schumer, Murray, others that have made it very clear that we are not voting for that bill in as it is. What we would like to see is there are some bipartisan bills that fund other parts of the government that could pass and then separate out this ICE funding. Too much money. The surge has to stop. The illegal entries into people's homes have to stop. They have to wear mandatory body cameras, which that agent in the Renee Good killing was not wearing. He had a cell phone on the unbelievable bounty system they have where they're picking up legal citizens, putting them in a car, and then we think they get some kind of bonus for doing it. The training, which was five months, going down to 47 days in honor of President Trump being the 47th president. And that's just the beginning of the overhaul, the complete overhaul that must be made to our immigration and border enforcement. We just you can't just sit there and say life goes on as normal. When I've had two of my constituents who are innocent, no criminal record killed, and two of the three homicides in Minneapolis were committed by federal agents. Performance comes down to controlling what you can. For tennis pro Jessica Pagula, that means starting with the air around her. She can't control her opponent or the match, but she can control her rest and recovery. That's why she's trusted Blue Air for five years and counting. Blue Signature air purifiers are engineered to perform and designed to impress with seven stages of advanced filtration, up to 10 times more odor removal and customizable colors and accessories. Shop blueair.com and use code signature 30 to save. Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today. At DSW, we ask the important questions, like what shoes are you going to wear? Whether you're prepping for wedding season, festival season or just planning the ultimate vacay the right shoes can make or break an RSVP So own the moment You got big plans and we got just the shoes at the perfect price of course Get ready to get ready with Designer Shoe Warehouse. Head to your DSW store or DSW.com today and let us surprise you. Minnesota U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar. Senator, it's always a pleasure and an honor to have you with us, but particularly right now. Thank you for your time tonight. Thank you. It was great to be on. Thanks, Rachel. More news ahead. Stay with us. Everywhere the Trump administration tries to put new camps, new ICE facilities and ICE prison camps, they're being pushed back. Now, this is something we've been trying to cover here on this show in recent weeks. I do feel like we're sort of starting to get our arms around it. But I just want to say to our friends in the national media, we could use some help on this story. I think this is an important story, and it'd be great to have more national media attention to it. The Trump administration really is trying to build Trump prison camps all over the country. And if you look, you will find that people all over the country, including in very unexpected places, almost uniformly are pushing back everywhere they're trying to do it. And they're pushing back in diverse and interesting ways. This is a really interesting emerging story. And again, we could use some more reportorial help with it. But let me tell you what we know. Last week, for example, it was Durant, Oklahoma. Local people there packed a meeting to say they don't want ICE turning a local warehouse into a giant prison. The local government in Durant, Oklahoma, then passed a brand new ordinance that gives them the power to say no to such a facility. Tomorrow, City Council in Oklahoma City is planning to address local concerns about a proposed ice prison there on the south side of Oklahoma City. Up in New Jersey, Roxbury, New Jersey, locals there started protesting like mad against ice, reportedly wanting to convert a half-million-square-foot warehouse in Roxbury into an ice prison camp. After those protests, the all-Republican local government in Roxbury, New Jersey, passed a resolution saying, no, you are not allowed to build that here. Down in Texas, Hutchins, Texas, again, a local protest against a proposed ICE prison, followed by the mayor in that city saying they are not going to allow anything like that to be built in Hutchins, Texas. In New York State, Republican-leaning Orange County, similar story. Packed town halls, packed public meetings, and then local elected officials saying, no, you will not be allowed to build a prison camp here. Kansas City, Missouri, after ICE said they wanted to build a prison in KC, the city council passed a five-year ban on building any non-municipal detention facility, any non-city detention facility. Social Circle Georgia, local Republican officials saying they will not let ICE turn a vacant warehouse there into a huge prison camp as well. Protests in Salt Lake City, Utah, we reported last week on dozens of people turning out in the early morning in deep, dense, cold fog because they heard that ICE was coming to inspect the local warehouse site there as a potential location for a new ICE prison. Locals then protested a local real estate company that was reportedly handling the potential sale of that site to ICE. Well, now that local real estate firm has announced this weekend that they have no plans to sell that local warehouse to the federal government for any purpose. And the list of communities pushing back keeps growing. Protesting in Hagerstown, Maryland this past week, Senator Chris Van Holland and their Congresswoman April McLean Delaney in attendance. In Hudson, Colorado, which is about 35 miles east of Boulder, protesting against a planned ICE prison there. In Merrimack, New Hampshire, which is a scrappy, no-nonsense New England town where I've got family ties, hundreds of people packed a Merrimack, New Hampshire town meeting, denouncing a proposed immigration prison there. And now the Merrimack Town Council has written to state and federal officials opposing that planned facility. And in the state legislature, Democrats in the New Hampshire state legislature are pushing legislation that would prevent any state or local funds being used for immigration prisons anywhere in the whole state. In Hanover County, Virginia, watch for this this week. Residents in Hanover County are preparing to attend their board of supervisors meeting the day after tomorrow, this Wednesday, January 28th, to tell their board of supervisors that they need to stand against a new immigrant prison facility that is planned for that county as well. Again, that's Hanover County, Virginia. And those are very disparate locations with very different politics and very different diverse communities. But you see pushback everywhere. even as all these local residents all over the country and all these different kinds of places are all pushing back against the Trump administration's efforts to build new camps, to build ICE prison camps and ICE facilities in their towns and cities, even as that happens. Something really, really remarkable happened this weekend inside one of the camps they've already built, inside one of the largest immigration prisons in the country. A witness who was there to see what happened, who got tape of what happened, is going to join us here live next. Stay with us. We learned it was happening when a lawyer named Eric Lee arrived at one of these camps at what they call the South Texas Family Residential Center in South Texas, in Dilley, Texas. Eric Lee arrived there for a meeting with his clients, but then while he was waiting, he was suddenly rushed out of the building by guards. And Mr. Lee then began filming what was happening. I'm outside of the Dilley facility here in South Texas. There's a demonstration of detainees taking place inside right now. We were all asked to leave. There's a drone flying up ahead right now. it's an extremely bizarre situation. You can hear them shouting. Can you hear that? They're shouting, let us out, let us out. There's people in blue shirts. Again, there's drones flying up ahead. there appear to be hundreds of people through the crack that I can see. That was Saturday in Dilley, Texas. And we do have an aerial shot of what was happening behind those walls. The Associated Press used a drone to capture these remarkable images of this, effectively, prison camp, this detention facility, and the protest within it. These are immigrant families, men, women, and children, effectively imprisoned at this Texas facility, and they're holding their own peaceful protest inside the prison walls this weekend. The signs they're holding included ones that said in Spanish, Liberty for the kids, libertad para los niños. Let the kids go from this prison. According to what lawyer Eric Lee was later able to learn from people inside, He says the prisoners had heard about the huge protest and general strike in Minneapolis on Friday, and they wanted to support it all the way down in South Texas behind prison walls. Joining us now is immigration attorney Eric Lee. Mr. Lee, thank you very much for being here. I appreciate your time. Thanks for having me. Bye. What should we understand about this Dilley facility and what happened here on Saturday? I could tell from your affect when you were filming this that this struck you as a really remarkable occurrence. Well, it was. And if I can show an image that my five-year-old client drew today that she wanted me to show this program, their name is the El Gamals. They've been detained in Dilley for eight months. They are two five-year-old twins. You can see at the top. I am five years old and the sad detained children behind bars are saying, let us go. Let us go. This is a family that has been persecuted by the Trump administration, not for anything that they did, but because of the crimes of a relative. They are suffering immensely, calling almost every day, begging for help, begging for the American population to pay attention to the conditions that exist inside this facility. And last week, an immigration judge denied them bond, claiming that because they had insufficient assets and insufficient property, that these children were going to remain in detention, possibly for years as we continue to exhaust their appeals. Their name is El Gamal. We urge everybody who's watching to fight for their release and for the release of every single child, mother and father in this terrible facility. how much transparency is there about the um the the the quality of life inside these facilities and the way people are being treated how much do you uh i feel like you have a visibility into how people are living there well what we know is from the detainees they tell us that the water is putrid mothers have to mix baby formula with water that stinks there's bugs in the food my client one of my clients in this El Gamal family was vomiting from pain in the hallway as he suffered from appendicitis. And the officials there told him, take a Tylenol and come back in three days. That's the type of treatment that is happening in this facility. And I have to say that it was referred to earlier as Trump prison camps. This facility was founded by Barack Obama and the Democratic Party in 2014. This is being expanded by Trump, certainly. The conditions are worsening. There's no question about that. But this is a bipartisan policy, the product of 30 years, 25 years of mass detention by Democratic and Republican administrations alike. This facility was open, as you said, during the Obama administration. My understanding is that it It was closed during the Biden administration and then reopened by Trump. That that facility, though, is right now one of just a number of large scale prison camps that Trump administration wants to operate all around the country. Access to the kind that you have to support your clients is key to us understanding the scale of what they're trying to do here. Eric Lee, thank you very much for being with us. I appreciate your time tonight. Thank you. All right. We'll be right back. Stay with us. All right. This has been a very, very busy news night. We started off this hour with news reported in part by The Atlantic magazine that Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bravino was being essentially demoted, stripped of his title of being Border Patrol Commander at large. MS Now has matched that story with a single source at this point. But it does look like there is significant change happening in terms of the character and size of the presence of federal agents in Minneapolis with that high-profile provocateur of Border Patrol commander Gregory Bovino leaving Minneapolis as soon as tonight or possibly tomorrow. All right, we'll keep you posted. That does it for me for now. Hey, everyone, it's Chris Hayes. This week on my podcast, Why Is This Happening? How to Stop Dictators. You have to make it clear to people who are in positions of influence, not just in government, but also maybe even in your local community, that democracy is at stake and what we do plays a role in the outcome. That's the only way that you get people to actually take action. That's this week on Why Is This Happening. Search for Why Is This Happening wherever you're listening right now and follow.

© 2026 GrayBeam Technology Privacy v0.1.0 · ac93850 · 2026-04-03 22:43 UTC