We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Attempting to reconnect
Daniel Davis / Deep Dive · 4.5K views · 257 likes Short
Analysis Summary
Worth Noting
Positive elements
- This video provides a critical counter-perspective on the 'liberation' narrative often found in mainstream media, specifically regarding the continuity of power structures after regime changes.
Be Aware
Cautionary elements
- The host uses 'motive attribution' to claim that any humanitarian justification for war is a conscious lie to cover for oil seizure, which may discourage nuanced analysis of foreign policy.
Influence Dimensions
How are these scored?About this analysis
Knowing about these techniques makes them visible, not powerless. The ones that work best on you are the ones that match beliefs you already hold.
This analysis is a tool for your own thinking — what you do with it is up to you.
Related content covering similar topics.
Tehran’s Shahran oil depot on fire
CNN
Dr. SHIVA® LIVE: Workers Anti-War Summit. Mobilization Against Trump-Netanyahu Regime.
Dr. SHIVA Ayyadurai, MIT PhD
Former Israeli ambassador on the possibility of ground troops in Iran
ABC News
Trump says he believes the U.S. is doing "very well" in war with Iran #shorts
CBS News
Why America's War In Middle East for "Freedom" is an Illusion I – Prof. Jiang Xueqin
Prof Jiang Media
Transcript
I'm cautiously optimistic. Unless he puts boots on the ground, then he's going to lose me. We'll see for now. Um I just don't get what liberals don't get about liberation. I see so much happiness. I see it in Venezuela. I see it here in Iran. Um could we skip the part where we talk about, oh, they had so many different reasons for going to war, regime change, and we got to get rid of the nukes and they were supporters of terrorism. It's all of it. How about this? This was a fascist theocracy and nothing in the Middle East was ever going to get better while they were still there [ __ ] everything up. >> Look at all the liberation in Venezuela. Really? Venezuelans are celebrating in the street because they have been liberated. All I saw was a two-hour military operation, a snatch and grab, which was coordinated on the inside by a backstabbing vice president, apparently, Dulce Rodriguez, where she basically handed over on a silver platter Maduro and his wife. Everything that Maduro had built and all of his vast empire are all still in place. And then, of course, we get into all the things that they're this theocratic regime and they're this terrible people. And and then economy just waves off all the things. It's not just the nuclear weapons. It's not just the missiles. It's it's kind of all that, but s really it gets down to the fact that they have a governing philosophy we don't like. So, let's just go kill them and just drive them out and then liberate those people. Like, well, I guess you're going to liberate their oil, too. But they're all saying, "We want our own selves to have our own government, our own leadership, and we'll be the ones that are going to do it. Nobody's going to force it on us from the outside." But Bill Maher doesn't care about that. Kelsea Ras doesn't care about that. Apparently, President Trump at all all these people, merchants of death, all they want is an asset. They don't care how many people die in the process to get it.
Video description
This shows its not just the Admin that lusts for war... Here Bill Maher @billmaher exposes how he falls for the rhetoric that these wars have been about "liberation" of oppressed peoples, by claiming the Venezuelans are free and happy today. Uh... You realize, right Mr. Maher, that there was no REGIME change in Venezuela, only the exchange of the leader from Maduro to Rodriguez. The entire rest of the corrupt, oppressive regime and all its supporters and enablers are still fully in place. That operation was about securing seizure of the Venezuelan oil production, and nothing more. This massive effort to bring war to the entire Middle East over Iran is likewise not about 'freedom' or the protection of protesters. It's not even about long range missiles or an alleged nuclear weapons program (and by the way, the odds are now through the roof that they are now racing to a bomb beyond our ability to obesrve or monitor; we are likely pushing them to do what we claim to have sought to prevent: getting a nuclear bomb). It's about destroying the Iranian regime, replacing it with one of our choosing (Trump's words, not mine), and about seizing control of Iranian oil. That's the ugly truth, and people like Mr. Maher are useful tools to spread the fiction that its about human rights and freedom.