We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Attempting to reconnect
'Don't feed the pig': For all of his unpopularity, corruption may bring Trump's downfall
The Rachel Maddow Show · 44:46 · 112d ago
"Be aware of 'argument flooding' where a long list of local events is used to create the impression of a unified national consensus that may not be as monolithic as presented."
Transparency
TransparentPrimary Technique
Bandwagon effect
Pressuring you to adopt a belief or behavior because it appears to be gaining momentum. 'Everyone is switching,' 'don't get left behind.' Combines social proof with urgency — not only is everyone doing it, but the window to join is closing.
IPA bandwagon technique (1937); information cascades (Bikhchandani et al., 1992)
The episode catalogs various local protests against ICE and the Trump administration, using a 'snowplow naming' anecdote as a lighthearted entry point into a serious discussion of 'Abolish ICE' sentiment. Beneath the reporting, it uses a rapid-fire list of geographic locations to create a sense of inevitable momentum and social proof for specific tactics like 'noise protests' at hotels.
Worth Noting
This episode provides a detailed map of specific local resistance tactics and the geographic spread of current anti-ICE protests across the US.
Be Aware
The use of 'argument flooding'—listing dozens of cities in rapid succession—is designed to make the listener feel that dissent is the only 'reasonable' or 'American' position, bypassing critical evaluation of the individual legal cases involved.
Influence Dimensions
How are these scored?Pathos
Appealing to your emotions — fear, joy, anger, sadness — to make an argument feel compelling. Rather than persuading through evidence, it works by putting you in an emotional state where you're more receptive. The emotion becomes the proof.
Aristotle's Rhetoric; Kahneman's System 1 processing
Intensity amplification
Inflating the importance, drama, or shock value of information using superlatives, alarming framing, and emotional language. Once your alarm system activates, you stop evaluating proportionality.
Cultivation theory (Gerbner, 1969); availability heuristic (Tversky & Kahneman, 1973)
In-group/Out-group framing
Leveraging your tendency to automatically trust information from "our people" and distrust outsiders. Once groups are established, people apply different standards of evidence depending on who is speaking.
Social Identity Theory (Tajfel & Turner, 1979); Cialdini's Unity principle (2016)
Loaded language
Using emotionally charged words where neutral ones would be more accurate. Calling the same policy 'reform' vs. 'gutting,' or the same people 'freedom fighters' vs. 'terrorists,' triggers different reactions to identical facts. The word choice does the persuading.
Hayakawa's Language in Thought and Action (1949); Lakoff's framing (2004)
Character flattening
Reducing a complex person to one defining trait — hero, villain, genius, fool — stripping away nuance that would complicate the narrative. Once someone is labeled, everything they do gets interpreted through that lens.
Fundamental attribution error (Ross, 1977); Propp's narrative archetypes (1928)
About this analysis
Knowing about these techniques makes them visible, not powerless. The ones that work best on you are the ones that match beliefs you already hold.
This analysis is a tool for your own thinking — what you do with it is up to you.
Transcript
We want to remember women that took that first step. I'm teaching future possibilities. The girls like hearing the story about Rosa Parks and the fact that she wasn't moving out of her seat. The girls like to hear that because they said she was a strong woman. When the girls see these role models that have made great strides, they start to get a sense of confidence in what they can do. It empowers them and it gives them hope that they can do anything that they want to do. That winning feeling you love? Take it everywhere you go with the Hollywood Casino app. Real money wins on all your favorite games, including exclusive titles and app-wide cash jackpots that hit all day, every day. The casino floor is now at your fingertips. New players bet $5 and get 300 bonus spins, plus up to $500 back in casino credits if you lose $10 plus in your first 24 hours. Hollywood Casino. Download and play today. Must be 21 plus. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Thanks to you at home for being with us. this out. Really, really happy to have you here. This is the time of year when a number of cities do this, but I've been particularly watching the great city of Chicago because this is the time of year when the city of Chicago asks its residents to please come up with new names for the city's new snowplows. Now, again, a number of cities do this. Chicagoans are particularly good at naming their snowplows. For example, in recent years, winning names in Chicago have included a lot of very Chicago-specific terms. So, like, as a shout-out to the Sears Tower a couple of years ago, Chicago christened a new snowplow, the Sears Plower. Okay, the great Ernie Banks from the Chicago Cubs, Mr. Sunshine, right? In his honor, we get the new plow, Ernie, not Ernie Banks, but Ernie Snowbanks. Yes. The south side of Chicago is the baddest part of town. If you go down there, you better just be aware of a man named Leroy Plow. Bad, bad Leroy Plow. Yes. In honor of the great Walter Payton, running back for the Bears, one of the all-time greats, Chicago named one new snowplow, Salter Payton. Salter Payton. Speaking of da Bears, We also got, of course, Da Plow. One of the best ones from last year was Control Salt Delete. It's all very good. It's all very good. Well, this year, guess what seems to be at least one of the leading nominees for new snowplow name this year in Chicago? It's Abolish Ice. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Abolish ice. Get it. It's a snowplow. Get it. It's a salt truck. Get it. The naming contest is still open in Chicago for this year. But Mayor Brandon Johnson has taken note online about abolish ice as a potential new snowplow name, which is very funny and also very obviously. It's like the obvious choice for this year. You know, one of the Chicago area protests that we saw against ICE, against Trump's federal agents and their attack on that city, was an almost daily protest. I guess I should say almost nightly protest outside one particular hotel in the Chicago suburbs where Trump's federal agents were staying. People showed up there every day and specifically every night, all night until dawn, every night, being as loud as possible, trying to make themselves as annoying as possible for the federal agents who were inside that hotel, presumably trying to sleep. Also, you know, making the hotel itself maybe regret that booking with those federal agencies. We saw that technique first, I think, earlier this year in Southern California, when Trump launched his first big attack on Los Angeles. In June, we saw people holding loud, loud nightly protests at hotels hosting ICE agents in Pasadena and in Burbank and in Arcadia and in Montebello and in Long Beach and in Downey and in Glenda, all over the Los Angeles area in Southern California. In September, we saw it on the East Coast, Medford, Massachusetts, people protesting loudly overnight. No justice, no sleep. Medford, Massachusetts, at a hotel where ICE agents were staying. We saw it last month in Charlotte, North Carolina, at a Hilton hotel in Charlotte, where ICE agents were staying in northeast Charlotte, North Carolina. We just saw it 10 days ago in the Minneapolis suburbs as Trump started sicking his federal agents on Minneapolis and St. Paul. I should tell you this weekend there was a huge protest, a really, really big one. Thousands of people turned out in Minneapolis this weekend to protest against ICE and against what Trump's federal agents have been doing in that city. I think that organizers look at the wind and the cold. Organizers, I think, knew they were going to get Minnesotans to turn out in pretty good numbers for this protest this weekend. You could guess that from seeing the number of spontaneous neighborhood protests that have sprung up all over the Twin Cities against Trump's agents as they have attacked people. Even so, I'm not sure anybody expected it would be thousands of people who turned out this weekend on Saturday on a day when the temperature was right around 10 degrees Fahrenheit with that stiff wind blowing as well. The other major city Trump is now attacking is Columbus, Ohio. People there are not taking it lying down either. Here's a really good report from local channel for WCMH in Columbus, Ohio. Watch this. It's a noisy night here at the Cambria Hotel in Polaris, where ICE officials are allegedly staying. People are blasting music, their car horns, and ringing bells to send a message that they will do whatever it takes to get ice out of Columbus. They're calling it no sleep for ice, and people say they're here to support their family and neighbors. According to social media reports, this comes after a group gathered last night at the Embassy Suites Hotel on the northeast side of the city near Westerville after discovering where ice officials were staying locally. One woman I spoke with says she was there until about 3 a.m. last night. She says she's done this for the last several nights and doesn't plan to stop until ICE does. For others, this is their first time, but they too say they will do this as long as it takes until ICE leaves Columbus. Maybe they're tired tomorrow and they won't maybe take more of our neighbors in custody tomorrow. Maybe they'll be a little cranky and move a little slower. Maybe some can get away. Just making them uncomfortable like they make everybody else uncomfortable. I mean, hopefully just a little bit of unrest like this is, you know, better than nothing. Just sitting at home on my couch. Columbus police are also on scene. And earlier today, more community members rallied against what they call aggressive ICE activity in their neighborhoods. Hundreds of people gathered in Westerville for a protest to voice their opposition with one clear message. ICE is not welcome here. Chance filled the streets as protesters marched, waved signs and demanded ICE leave their neighborhoods, turning frustration and fear into a loud show of resistance. resistance. It's really just scary. You have to be scared anywhere you walk, anywhere you go. And, you know, a lot of people out here aren't very, don't know their rights. I have a baby child that fits the description of what these people are looking for, kidnapping and disappearing. Half of them we don't know, well, even where they're at. Protesters say as long as the reported increased ICE activity persists, they will not hide and will do whatever it takes to force ICE agents out of the city. You're not welcome here. Our immigrants are our neighbors. They're our family. They're welcome. They pay taxes. They help the community. You do nothing for us. That's local Channel 4, the NBC station in Columbus, Ohio. Columbus, Ohio, this weekend, in the midst of a surge of Trump's federal agents grabbing people in that city, you see some of what's happening there in terms of the local response. We've also seen a lot of reports from Columbus and the Columbus area about mutual aid and Know Your Rights trainings and churches coming together to try to figure out how they can keep people safe in their community against this attack from the federal government. Louisiana has also been the subject of similar types of attacks from federal agents in the last couple of weeks. And as such, this was the scene at one Marriott Hotel near the French Quarter in New Orleans this weekend. This happened right after Border Patrol Commander Greg Bovino was reportedly seen at this hotel in New Orleans. When those images started circulating on social media, people in New Orleans turned out, again, to be as loud as possible at that hotel. We Americans have always had a special knack for making ourselves annoying to others. Just ask anybody from any other country. But now in city after city in our own country, from Southern California to Chicago to Massachusetts to North Carolina to Columbus, Ohio to New Orleans, Americans are putting that talent to use. Americans are making themselves purposely annoying at hotels for a very specific cause when ICE agents are staying there. There were protests at a Home Depot in Oakland, California this weekend. As that company continues to allow its stores and its parking lots to be used by Trump's agents to attack immigrants, people want Home Depot, to at least object to that, to at least tell the government that they should not use their stores and parking lots for that purpose. You're starting to see protests against Home Depots all across the country. There were protests this weekend at the San Luis Obispo County Sheriff's Office in California. People protesting against ICE activity at the county jail there. Protests this weekend against ICE and against Trump's immigration raids in Paducah, Kentucky. Also, we saw a similar protest in Pontiac, Michigan this weekend. In Bentonville, Arkansas this weekend, people protested with what they called signs of fascism. Literal signs about what fascist governance looks like. Controlled mass media identifying enemies to blame. Sort of a rip from the headlines kind of vibe there. Protest this weekend at the Pueblo, Colorado airport. There's an airline that operates at that airport. It's called Key Lime Air or Denver Air Connection. And that company has been linked to ICE deportation flights. And so Colorado residents are increasingly protesting against Key Lime Air and Denver Air Connection. basically wanting them kicked out of Colorado airports. I should tell you, there were protests at the Denver airport before these protests at the Pueblo airport. And after the Denver airport protests against Key Lime Air, the Denver City Council last week responded. They voted to block Key Lime Air from an expansion at the Denver airport. One city councilor telling Colorado Newsline, quote, this is where the rubber starts to hit the road when we start to talk about what are we going to do in Denver about what's happening at the federal level? She said, quote, if an aviation grant, meaning an aviation grant for the Denver International Airport is what's on the line here, then it's very clear to me what the city's stand should be on that. She said, quote, I have no interest in supporting this deportation machine. The city council voted to deny them that request. There was protest in eastern North Carolina this weekend with the Reverend William Barber against Republicans reengineering that state to get rid of one of the last remaining black congressional districts in the south There were protests this weekend in Boulder Colorado against Trump bizarre new plan to just close one of the premier geosciences labs in the world Trump just out of the blue demanded the closure, full stop, of the National Center for Atmospheric Research, NCAR, in Colorado. I'm not sure he understands what atmospheric research is, maybe. Maybe he may think that that weather forecast just happened like from fortune cookies or something. I don't know what he thinks he's going to win by getting rid of, again, one of the premier geoscience labs in the world. Absolutely crucial, among other things, to severe weather research for the benefit of the American people and the American government. He wants to shut it down. Hundreds of Coloradans, including Democratic Congressman Joe Neguse and Democratic U.S. Senator John Hickenlooper, came out amid the protesters this weekend to protest against that new announcement from Trump in Boulder. There were protests this weekend right after President Trump put his own name up on the Kennedy Center in Washington. Some public officials were at that protest, including Senator Chris Van Hollen, but mostly it was it was regular Washingtonians who just turned out in costume. and in drag and in a general sense of astonishment and revulsion at this president and what we are learning about the lengths he will go to to serve himself. And, you know, I don't know where all these various types of protests end up going, right? I don't know where they all end up in history and in our time. I don't think any of us can know that sort of in the abstract and in advance and while this is all happening. But we do know that his trend lines aren't good. And the kinds of causes these protesters are sticking up for are ascending in popularity as his popularity sinks. His popularity is sinking, not just overall, but on every issue area over time. And public protests against him, against him generally, and against him on all these specific issue areas are persisting and persisting and persisting. everywhere in the country over time. They're not letting up. And I don't exactly know how this got into the mix here, but I'll just show you. This is from the last couple of weeks as well. This is not the United States. This is the city of Sofia, capital city of Bulgaria. I'm showing you these protests because Bulgaria recently saw its prime minister and his whole government resign. in the face of these protests, in the face of Bulgarians turning to the streets in widespread and increasingly large nonviolent protests against their own government. This is from the BBC, quote, The government of Bulgaria's prime minister has resigned after protesters took to the streets and cities across the country and filled the center of the capital, Sofia. The prime minister's dramatic move came ahead of a vote of no confidence in parliament. In a TV address, the prime minister said, quote, We hear the voice of citizens protesting against the government, both young and old, have raised their voices for our resignation. He said, quote, this civic energy must be supported and encouraged. Protesters had accused his right-leaning government of widespread corruption. The government had already scrapped a controversial budget plan for next year that was widely seen as self-dealing by the administration. They had already scrapped that controversial budget plan in response to the demonstrations in the capital and elsewhere in that country. And then between 50 and 100,000 people turned out in the central triangle of power and independent square in the capital city of Sofia. They're all calling for the government to go. And the government went. Protesters projected the words resignation. And mafia out projected them onto the parliament building. Protesting widespread corruption. Mafia out. Resign. The word for resign in Bulgarian is here in this image. I do not speak Bulgarian, but I think the pronunciation is Ostovka. And the reason it says Ostafka on this pink pig is because the pink pig became the symbol of that protest movement against that corrupt government, a symbol of the decadence and corruption of that government that the people all over that country decided to protest against and protest they did until that government stood down. Prime Minister resigned. In the New York Times, the headline about the prime minister resigning, his government resigning, quoted the protesters, quote, don't feed the pig, the anti-corruption call that helped topple a government. As we head toward the end of this first year of Trump being back in office, the corruption story in this country is becoming more and more central to people's understanding of what Donald Trump and the Trump era Republican Party have to offer the country. I mean, people don't like what Trump is doing on immigration broadly. They don't like the cruelty. They don't like masked secret police roaming around in unmarked cars and grabbing people off the street on the basis of their race and shooting pepper balls at people and breaking people's car windows and chasing people in the church parking lots and daycare centers. Yeah, it turns out people do not like that broadly. And that is why you are seeing protests against it in blue states and red states all across this country. But on top of that, we've learned from new reporting in The Washington Post in the last few days that the Trump administration also just fast-tracked a billion-dollar government contract for self-deportation promotion to a random pro-Trump donor whose company had never had a government contract before. The Washington Post based this on records they say they reviewed. The Department of Homeland Security says there's nothing wrong with this at all, but it is a billion dollars of your money. going to some random pro-Trump donor who's never done anything like this before, but somehow the Homeland Security Department had to fast-track him this money, your money, a billion dollars of your money. Remember the so-called border czar, Tom Homan, used to be ubiquitous in threatening immigrants on behalf of Trump? The same Tom Homan who is reportedly on tape receiving $50,000 in cash, in cash, green money, in a fast food bag from Kava. He reportedly received this money from undercover FBI agents in a bribery sting that was mysteriously shut down once Trump got back into office. Tom Homan initially said he had done nothing wrong, but he refused to address what he had done with the money. He later said, oh, actually, he didn't take the money at all. But reporting first from MS Now, later matched by a number of other news outlets, led members of Congress to make some formal inquiries on this. Among the questions still unanswered about that reported bribery scam for Trump's top immigration guy is the question of whether or not Tom Homan actually did get the money. And if he did, did he actually keep the money? Did he keep the $50,000 he reportedly took in that paper bag, in that FBI sting operation from undercover FBI agents on tape? Again, that's $50,000 of your money. Ten business days from today is the deadline for the Justice Department to hand over to Democratic U.S. senators a whole bunch of its records on that bribery sting, including the tape. And any information the government has on what Tom Homan might have done with the 50 G's from the FBI that he reportedly accepted on tape, which he now says, oh, he never got it all. That said, there's more new MSNOW reporting on the FBI's shepherding of its own resources under the leadership of Trump's handpicked FBI director, a right wing podcaster named Cash. That reporting might be a bit of a distraction from those other corruption allegations right now at the FBI. MS now reporting that Patel has demanded that the FBI use specially configured armored BMW SUVs for driving him around because he likes them better than the suburbans that all other high ranking government officials use. MS now also reporting that he tried to demand that the FBI should buy him new private jets because he thought the old ones were outdated. it. Heaven forbid he'd be seen in a government SUV like the other government agencies, right? Or that he'd be seen in an outdated private jet. It's so embarrassing. I mean, you can understand, though, why he might feel a little competitive. The Homeland Security Department did reportedly purchase two new private jets for Trump's Homeland Security Secretary Christine Elm for 172 million of your dollars, right? Seems like a great stewardship of your money, right? How about the 15 million dollars of your money that the U.S. military just handed to a little-known drone company soon after the president's son, Don Jr., was put on its board and given shares in that company? Weird, their revenue like tripled in a few months after Don Jr. got on the board and got some shares. That's so weird. I wonder how they got that military contract. How about the $600 million that another Don Jr. company just got from his dad's defense department? It's, quote, biggest ever contract from the Pentagon. It's the largest loan ever made by the Office of Strategic Capital at the Pentagon. What a coincidence that that largest loan ever made went to a firm that just had Don Jr. buy into it. Don Jr., of course, says this was totally on the up and up. Nothing wrong. Just a crazy coincidence, right? We're going to talk tonight about CBS News being humiliated. CBS News having a reputation it took decades and generations to build, having that reputation just dragged into a tar pit by the new owners of its parent company who appear to be trying to destroy one of the most important news brands and news organizations in the world in order to curry favor with President Donald Trump so Trump will allow them to buy yet more media companies, including CNN, which they reportedly have promised to radically change and make more to Trump's liking if only they will let him have it. The president's own son-in-law, Jared Kushner, with money from the Saudis, only recently pulled out of that proposed deal, which isn't disgusting at all. Like I said, it looks to our English-speaking Western eyes like Ogtabka, but I think it's pronounced Ostopka. Resign. Don't feed the pig. Worked in Bulgaria. We're going to talk tonight about the Trump administration flouting a very high profile, newly passed, brand new law that requires them to release all of their files related to Jeffrey Epstein and his child sex trafficking ring. We're going to talk tonight about the hugely embarrassing debacle at CBS News and this now open effort by the president to have state TV in this country, to have government controlled television and specifically government controlled television news. now that we have total clarity that that's what he's after. And we know that the billionaires and executives who control these companies are apparently more than willing to go along with it. We're going to talk with Congressman Jamie Raskin tonight about what we, the country, can do to defend ourselves, to defend our democracy against that. You may be surprised at some of what he has to say about how to think about that problem, about what our options are as a country. but you know the shortest day of the year um is behind us now it was yesterday today is the day when um nighttime starts getting a little shorter every night when daytime starts getting a little longer every day Today the day we start getting a little more light with each passing day every single day from here on out Donald Trump's party has lost control of the House of Representatives, effectively. Multiple discharge petitions there now moving bills without the Republican Party's permission, despite the fact that they nominally control the House. The Heritage Foundation, which brought us Project 2025. Heritage Foundation is now imploding with senior staffers from every department fleeing that far-right organization in disgust. The Turning Point USA conservative movement conference that was held this weekend was highlighted by the most famous people who spoke at that conference, all screaming insults and accusations at each other and pledging to be one another's mortal enemy. Couldn't happen to a nicer group. The president's two most high profile and ambitious allies in Congress, Marjorie Taylor Greene and Elise Stefanik, are now both leaving Congress and in Stefanik's case, quitting her run for New York governor. Both of them apparently storming out of the MAGA movement in disgust. And thousands of people are marching against Trump in 10 degree weather in Minnesota. And people all over the country right at this moment are banging pots and pans outside some random suburban hotel where Trump's ICE agents are staying the night. And Chicago's about to get a really cute new snowplow named Abolish ICE. You never know what's going to turn the tide, what's going to make all the difference. But, I mean, look around. It's getting brighter every day now. we got a lot to get to tonight we'll be right back what do you know about the family detention center in dilly texas it's where our government imprisons immigrant parents children and even newborns a place with putrid drinking water food with bugs and worms and even a confirmed measles outbreak these conditions are unsafe and inhumane. The Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, or RAICES, is the only legal aid provider inside Dili, day in and day out. We're there right now, defending immigrants' rights to due process and filing emergency petitions to free families illegally detained. You can fuel our fight to protect the rights of our children, our neighbors, and all of us. Donate at freeallfamilies.org. That's freeallfamilies.org. This message comes from the International Rescue Committee. Right now, in places like Gaza, Sudan, and Ukraine, conflict and disaster have forced millions of families into temporary shelters without basic supplies and in urgent need of aid. With your help, the International Rescue Committee is on the ground in more than 40 countries delivering food clean water shelter and medical care where it's needed most donate today by visiting rescue.org slash rebuild that winning feeling you love take it everywhere you go with the hollywood casino app real money wins on all your favorite games including exclusive titles and app-wide cash jackpots that hit all day every day the casino floor is now at your fingertips new players bet five dollars and get 300 bonus spins plus up to $500 back in casino credits if you lose $10 plus in your first 24 hours. Hollywood Casino. Download and play today. Must be 21 plus. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. It was the appointment of a sort of random new labor secretary, of all things, that got it going. It was 2017, first year of Trump's first term in office, and he picked a low-profile former federal prosecutor from Florida to be labor secretary. Not the flashiest of cabinet nominees and not the flashiest of cabinet positions. Forgive me. But, you know, who's ever heard of Alex Acosta? He was really not a household name. But there was an investigative reporter in Florida at the time who saw Acosta's name in the papers because of that nomination. And it really, really rang a bell for her. She had remembered that that guy, back when he was U.S. attorney in Florida, his office had arranged a plea deal for a big finance guy. Um, that finance guy wasn't exactly a household name either. Um, but she thought there was a story there at the, at the time there were allegations that this finance guy had done some really bad stuff while this U S attorney's office under Alex Acosta, for some reason, they'd let this guy off the hook with just a brief stint in the County jail. And it had raised some eyebrows in Florida when it happened, but it had been about a decade and nobody had looked at it. This one reporter in Florida decided that she would give this story a closer look. She did more than a year of very difficult investigative reporting looking into that case. And after more than a year, she published this, quote, how a future Trump cabinet member gave a serial sex abuser the deal of a lifetime. That was the first of a three part series from Miami Herald investigative reporter Julie K. Brown. It was published November 2018. That was the piece that made Trump Labor Secretary Alex Acosta a household name for the first time. It's also the reporting that made Jeffrey Epstein a household name. For her story, Julie K. Brown identified more than 80 of Epstein's alleged victims, dozens more than anybody had known about before. It was Julie K. Brown who revealed for the first time the full scope and nature of Epstein's alleged crimes. And that, of course, put fresh scrutiny on Trump's new labor secretary, Alex Acosta, whose office had let Epstein off the hook all those years ago with that inexplicable sweetheart deal in Florida. Brown's reporting was damning. It was also bulletproof. And it finally made it impossible to ignore what had happened to all those victims. Julie Kate Brown published her revelations about Epstein, as I said, November 2018. Three months later, a judge ruled that Acosta had broken the law when he did not notify the victims that he was giving Epstein that plea deal. Epstein was then arrested on federal child sex trafficking charges. Acosta had to resign as Trump's labor secretary. And here we are still today, seven years later, still feeling the shockwaves of Julie K. Brown's reporting. Her instincts, her reporting skills, her fearlessness in getting it into print. This past Friday was the deadline for DOJ to unseal all of its files related to Epstein. They were required by law, thanks to a bill passed by Congress and signed by President Trump, required by law to release all of the records in their possession to only redact personal information that could invade privacy of any of the victims. This Friday on that deadline, DOJ looked at that legal requirement and went, eh, maybe some of it. The DOJ did not release all of the Epstein files on Friday as they were legally compelled to do. They released only a small portion of them and they were very, very heavily redacted. DOJ also inexplicably removed some of the documents after they initially posted them, including one photo that showed Donald Trump. After people pointed out they'd done that, they put it back without much of an explanation. In Julie K. Brown's recent reporting for the Miami Herald, she says Epstein's victims are upset by the heavy redactions, by the small amount of material that's been released. More than a dozen of Epstein's victims have now written to Congress saying they want hearings to make sure DOJ follows the law with the disclosure of these files. And Julie K. Brown's reporting continues. Look at this, just posted online a few hours ago by Julie Brown. quote, in recent weeks, I have received a lot of new information about girls and young women who were in fact sexually trafficked to powerful men. This is not a hoax. Julie K. Brown joins us live here next. Stay with us. To tip off this NBA season on FanDuel, you can choose your own rewards, which means you can play your game any way you want. I get to choose my rewards? Yep. Great. Now, excuse me while I lock in. All customers choose your own reward right now in the FanDuel app. 21 plus and present in select states. 18 plus in Kentucky. Opt-in required. Rewards are non-withdrawable. Restrictions apply, including bonus and token expiration, leg requirement, and max wage amount. See full terms at fanduel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. CIDP can make your daily routine feel not so routine. The good news? With a self-injection for chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy, you have the option to treat at home. Discover more at CIDPSelfinjection.com and talk to your doctor. That's CIDPSelfinjection.com. Brought to you by Argenics. If you're a parent and want to help set up your child for success, then IXL is right for your family. As an effective and affordable online learning program, IXL covers math, language arts, science, and social studies using interactive practice problems for kids from pre-K to 12th grade. Listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at IXL.com slash 20. Visit IXL.com slash 20 to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price. Here's fresh reporting from Julie K. Brown on DOJ's botched release of the Epstein files this past Friday. She says, quote, the rollout did not go smoothly. Victims and the public were upset by the small amount of material, the heavy redactions and the government's failure to place any documents in the proper context. The digital download included hundreds of photographs, none of them labeled and did not include witness and victim statements made to the FBI. Quote, many of the redactions were of material that has previously been made public. Again, redactions of material that has previously been made public or that was supposed to be unsealed under the new law. Joining us now is Julie Kay Brown, investigative reporter for the Miami Herald, the woman who's reporting we can credit for knowing anything that we know about this story in the first place. Julie Kay Brown, it is really nice to see you again. Thank you for being here. Thank you. Julie, what have you been hearing from some of the Epstein survivors since the release of these documents on Friday? I think that it's starting really to turn into anger at this point, especially with a lot of these victims have found their own names that have been not redacted in some of this material that has come out. And they're quite frustrated because they see so many other redactions that are saying it almost appears as though the government made sure that they redacted the information that perhaps were clues or provided information about what happened in these cases or who was involved. But they didn't pay enough attention to making sure that they would protect the victim's identities. can you say more about um what you posted online tonight you said in recent weeks i've received a lot of new information about girls and young women who were in fact sexually trafficked two powerful men this is not a hoax can you tell us more about what you mean there well a lot of these women remember this goes back 20 years so a lot of them were quite young when this happened and now as this whole movement, this momentum has sort of snowballed, a lot of them are starting to talk to one another, and they've formed these groups and have been supporting each other. And more and more women are now coming forward and joining this group and talking to each other and bonding and helping with the effort to unseal these documents. So they've become stronger and stronger. They've created almost this movement together. And I think that has enabled them to start talking about exactly what their experiences were and who was trafficked to whom. And they just have similar experiences. And some of them have shared those experiences with me. They do not want to go public largely because they distrust the government Quite frankly most of them do not believe that Jeffrey Epstein killed himself They feel that the whole investigation into his death was very, you know, sloppy, sloppy at best. And there's all other signs point to this distrust. The fact that Ghislaine Maxwell has been moved to this cushy prison now that she had a, you know, an interview with the deputy attorney general, who, by the way, hasn't ever interviewed the victims. So there were and then you put on top of that the pushback by Trump and his administration on even releasing these files. All these things add up to the fact that they feel that they can't trust the government. So they're starting to try to figure out a way to find justice on their own, quite frankly. And one of the ways they're doing that is is to start talking to each other and supporting each other with the experiences that they had. And it's sort of a support group, if you will. And in the course of that, they're starting to feel more comfortable talking about these kinds of things that happened to them so many years ago that they were too traumatized in the past to talk about. Well, the statements of the women who you're talking about and with whom you've been speaking have affected not just public perception here, but have also created a new political environment around the story. They have changed the political weather around this, including in a way that is in some cases bipartisan, something that seemed impossible before they did what they've done. If anything drives the release of more of these files, it's going to be them. Julie Kay Brown, investigative reporter for the Miami Herald. Sorry, go ahead. I was just going to say that I also think that because they are now being finally listened to, that's another reason why I think the public is listening to them. People are believing them. And they are finding little bits and pieces here that also confirm some of their stories in these documents. So I think that is also helping them to move forward with pushing for more files to be released. I think that's exactly right. And I should tell you, Lawrence O'Donnell is going to have much, much, much more on this story at the top of this hour right after right after our show. Julie Kay Brown from the Miami Herald. Thank you so much, Julie. It's nice to see you. Thank you. All right. We've got much more news ahead. Stay with us. Here's Democratic Senator Brian Schatz of Hawaii. Here's how he put it. He said, quote, what's happening to CBS is a terrible embarrassment. And if executives think they can build shareholder value by avoiding journalism that might offend the mad king, they're about to learn a tough lesson. This is still America and we don't enjoy bull, bull pucky like this. Senator Brian Schatz did not use the word pucky, but he otherwise neatly summed up the fiasco that is unfurling over the loud objections of our respected colleagues and competitors at CBS News right now. It was just hours before 60 Minutes was going to air an in-depth piece on the alleged abuse and torture suffered by men who Trump sent to a brutal prison in El Salvador when CBS News's newly installed editor-in-chief spiked the story and wouldn't let it run. This newly hired conservative blogger, commentator turned news executive said she was holding the story for a later date because she believed it was not ready. The journalist who produced the segment and a note to her colleagues that was published by The New York Times called the decision to pull the story, quote, political. You'll recall it was only a few months ago that CBS and its parent company were bought by the family of one of Trump's billionaire supporters. And as part of the Trump administration's approval of that deal, CBS's new owners promised to install a Trump friendly, friendly conservative minder to keep an eye on the CBS newsroom. They also installed this new editor in chief who is now being accused by the journalist she oversees of politically interfering in their work. The reason this is causing a revolt is because this is how, bit by bit, the free press, the independent American news organizations that give us a free press, instead become state TV. And that is a matter not just for the billionaires who are playing with these things for their own benefit and the executives who have decided to enable them. It's also a matter of public interest. It's a matter of national interest. Earlier this month, Congressman Jamie Raskin wrote to CBS News and asked them to account for edits that appeared to have been made to a 60 minutes interview at President Trump's request. He said, quote, it's one thing for CBS to make independent editorial decisions protected by the First Amendment. It's quite another to make edits at the president's demand out of fear of retribution. The American people deserve to know whether their news is shaped by journalistic judgment or by Donald Trump. the American people deserve to know. Joining us now is Congressman Jamie Raskin of Maryland. He's the top Democrat on the Judiciary Committee in the House. Sir, it's nice to see you. Thanks for being here. You bet. You're a constitutional law professor. In addition to being a member of Congress, can you explain in non-lawyers' terms why it is a matter of national interest, a matter of our governance and our democracy, What happens at a privately owned news organization? Well, every ruler in the world would love to be able to control what private TV or private newspapers are publishing about them. And Donald Trump is using his power over the Federal Communications Commission to make it possible for him to have minders, either formally denominated minders or people like Barry Weiss, who are just going to do his bidding. And it's better really than state TV. It's state-controlled corporate TV, so they can continue to make millions or billions of dollars on it. But at the same time, they will not veer anywhere away from the politically correct official line of the government. And that's exactly what we're seeing in this really shocking episode related to 60 Minutes and the Seacott torture prison in El Salvador. Sure. In what ways are companies like CBS or Paramount or any of the parent companies involved here accountable to their shareholders, accountable to Congress, accountable to the people if they decide to be part of a plot like this by the government? Well, that's a good question. I mean, we haven't quite dealt with a situation like this before. And we're going to have to explore what are the different avenues for demanding accountability. But right now, you know, because of the sort of muscle that Trump is using over the FCC to control mergers and to extract particular points of concession from different broadcast networks, He's gaining real control over a lot of them and others he's gaining control over through different kinds of coercive manipulations. And a lot of them are just giving in. So it would take some shareholders of the different companies to begin to raise the issue. And it will take other truly independent media entities such as your own blowing the whistle on this. And maybe, you know, that would shame or humiliate someone like Barry Weiss into acting like, you know, a real journalist as opposed to, you know, a reporter on the payroll of Vladimir Putin in Moscow. And that's basically what's going on right now. They are acting like state controlled TV entities that are part of an inside power operation. Congressman, I want to ask you about some news that's broken since we've been on the air tonight. A federal judge has just ruled that the Trump administration denied due process to the men it deported to this prison in El Salvador, the subject of the 60 Minutes piece that we're talking about. For those men who are still in that prison or who have been who were sent abroad by the administration in that way, The judge is giving the government two weeks to either facilitate their return to the United States or otherwise provide them with hearings. I just wanted to get your reaction to that ruling tonight. Well, it's a necessary and very positive ruling. And I got to say that Judge Boesburg, who was originally a Bush appointee to the bench, has been very much of a hero in terms of upholding the due process rights of these Venezuelans who were sent overwhelmingly without evidence to El Salvador, simply claiming that they're members of criminal gangs, which the vast majority of them were not. And then they were subjected to truly brutal, cruel, 24-7 humiliation and torture there. They were told when they arrived at that prison, there's no day, there's no night here, this is hell. Welcome to hell and you will never leave. So just brutal totalitarian conditions. Finally, Venezuela was able to negotiate an exchange of prisoners to get them out of Salvador and back to Venezuela. But because they haven't had any due process, we literally don't know who these people were. Some of them may have been legally, you know, lawfully present in the United States. But there was no opportunity to hear anything. I mean, that's what due process is about. They're the two most beautiful words in the Constitution, maybe the two most beautiful words in the whole English language, because they separate people's liberty and their freedom from the arbitrary power of the state. that I had a Republican say to me on the floor the other day, well, you're not saying you're for due process for guilty people, are you? And I said, that's the whole point. We don't know if they're guilty until there's been due process. So Judge Boesberg has both tried to hold the government in contempt for disregarding his order, telling them to turn the planes around. And then he's also insisting that these people have due process hearings. Now, who knows whether the court will, in fact, you know, an appeals court will order that they come back to the states for this hearing or if it'd be done on Zoom. Who knows how they're going to work it out. But good for Judge Bozberg that he's actually taking the Constitution seriously. Congressman Jamie Ruskin, good to have you here tonight, sir. Thank you. We'll be right back. one last thing uh statistically speaking there's a pretty good chance you may find yourself on a train or in a plane or in an automobile in the next few days maybe if you're looking for something to listen to on your travels i will just give you this reminder that my new podcast which is called rachel maddow presents burn order is out now all six episodes are out it is free on any podcast app or you can listen directly online at ms.now slash burn order. That's it. Just a reminder. That does it for me tonight. Snoring? Gasping during sleep? Feeling fatigued? Wake up to ZetBound Terzepatide, the first and only FDA-approved prescription medicine for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and adults with obesity. ZetBound is an injectable prescription medicine that may help adults with moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and obesity to improve their OSA. Z-Bound should be used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity. Z-Bound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. Z-Bound contains terzepatide and should not be used with other terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Z-Bound is safe and effective for use in children. Do not share needles or pens or reuse needles. Don't take Z-Bound if allergic to it or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer or multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZEPBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes, depression, or suicidal thoughts before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking ZEPBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit ZetBound.Lily.com. ZetBound and its delivery device base in QuickPen are registered trademarks owned or licensed by Eli Lilly & Company, its subsidiaries, or affiliates.