bouncer
← Back

The New York Times · 99.3K views · 1.6K likes Short

Analysis Summary

40% Low Influence
mildmoderatesevere

“Be aware that the technical precision of the visual evidence is used to bridge a logical gap between 'the U.S. was in the area' and 'the U.S. definitely targeted this specific building.'”

Transparency Mostly Transparent
Primary technique

Appeal to authority

Citing an expert or institution to support a claim, substituting their credibility for evidence you can evaluate yourself. Legitimate when the authority is relevant; manipulative when they aren't qualified or when the citation is vague.

Argumentum ad verecundiam (Locke, 1690); Cialdini's Authority principle (1984)

Human Detected
98%

Signals

The content is a high-quality piece of investigative journalism featuring natural human narration, specific professional credits, and a detailed methodology that reflects human editorial judgment rather than synthetic generation.

Natural Speech Patterns Transcript includes natural filler words ('uh'), self-correction, and conversational phrasing ('our colleagues got in touch with us').
Institutional Provenance Produced by The New York Times Visual Investigations team with specific credits for journalists (Malachy Browne, etc.).
Original Investigative Process The script describes a first-person investigative methodology (matching architectural features, checking historical satellite imagery).

Worth Noting

Positive elements

  • This video provides a high-quality demonstration of how open-source intelligence (OSINT) can be used to verify civilian infrastructure status independently of government statements.

Be Aware

Cautionary elements

  • The use of 'precision' as a rhetorical tool to imply intentionality rather than just capability, which subtly guides the viewer toward a conclusion of deliberate targeting.

Influence Dimensions

How are these scored?
About this analysis

Knowing about these techniques makes them visible, not powerless. The ones that work best on you are the ones that match beliefs you already hold.

This analysis is a tool for your own thinking — what you do with it is up to you.

Analyzed March 13, 2026 at 16:07 UTC Model google/gemini-3-flash-preview-20251217
Transcript

This is the result of the single deadliest known attack in this war so far. This aerial image shows around 100 graves being dug after an elementary school was hit in a town called Minab in southern Iran. You can see excavators there, workmen digging, graves that are marked out to be dug. These were mostly children. On Saturday morning when the US and Israel started its attacks on Iran, our colleagues got in touch with us and said there were reports of a school being hit. After the attack, this information started to swirl. There were denials online that the US or Israel was responsible. The question was, could we verify what happened? The first videos that emerged after the strike show these massive plumes of smoke over Manab, what was being described as the school building that had been destroyed and uh children under the rubble. The challenge there is to verify that this building is in fact a school. There were reports that it was near a military base of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. So we started looking for military bases in that area. Found one that had been bombed and adjacent to that military base was the school. We were able to match the architectural features of the school, the contours of the building, the size of it with satellite imagery. Going back over historic satellite imagery, we could see that the building that the school is in was part of the IRGC compound in 2013. But by September 2016, it had been cordoned off into its own compound. There was a play area. You could see the bright pastel colors of the school walls and it very clearly became a school and wasn't part of the IRGC base. What we can see in the satellite imagery and the images from the ground is that more than half the building is gone. a very powerful explosion. A precision strike is required to do that. It's not secondary damage from a strike nearby. A precision strike is where an army will take the coordinates of a target, input that into their targeting system, or visually identify a target and lock onto it. We can see in the satellite imagery precision strikes that destroyed buildings or punched holes in the roofs of those buildings very precisely. Our reporting has shown this is characteristic of Israeli and US strikes. So far, the US hasn't confirmed or denied responsibility for the strike on the school. Defense Secretary Pete Hgset said, >> "We of course never target uh civilian targets, but we're we're taking a look at investigating that." At the same briefing, Dan Kaine, who's the US military joint chief's chairman, said that during the first 100 hours of operations over Iran, Israel was bombing in the north and the US was bombing in the south, which is where the school in Manab is located. So given that the US was operating in that area at the time, the evidence seems to be pointing at US responsibility.

Video description

Neither the U.S. nor Israel has yet taken responsibility for an airstrike that hit an elementary school in southern Iran on Feb. 28 at the same time as an attack on an adjacent Iranian military base. Malachy Browne of our Visual Investigations team explains what satellite imagery and other evidence tell us about who might be responsible for the deadliest known episode of civilian casualties since the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran. Video by Malachy Browne, Aaron Boxerman, Coleman Lowndes, Estelle Caswell and Mona Lalwani/The New York Times #iran #US #israel #war Read the story here: https://nyti.ms/4rXt0cB Subscribe: http://bit.ly/U8Ys7n More from The New York Times Video: http://nytimes.com/video ---------- Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.

© 2026 GrayBeam Technology Privacy v0.1.0 · ac93850 · 2026-04-03 22:43 UTC